THE CHURCH'S TEACHING ON INDULGENCES
Meaning of indulgence
Many people are familiar with this word but have no deep knowledge or understanding about it. Indulgences in the Catholic Church are not a thing of the past, they remain part of the Catholic doctrine today. Indulgence is one of the Catholic teachings that people misunderstand, some people see it as "buying of forgiveness", but in the real sense, indulgences are connected to God's mercy and the process of spiritual healing.
The word "Indulgence" comes from a Latin word "Indulgere" which means to be kind. An indulgence is the remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church, which, as the ministers of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints. This definition is according to the Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 1471. It is essential to note that indulgence does not forgive sin itself. It is like a process that removes the temporal wound or attachment of sin left after confession.
Before proceeding, let me clearly state that indulgence is not a sacrament and can never replace the sacrament of Penance. According to the definition of indulgence, we need to distinguish between eternal and temporal punishment. Eternal punishment is what separates us from God due to mortal sin, this separation can be healed through confession and repentance. Temporal punishment is the temporal effect of sin that requires purification through prayer, charity or after death in purgatory.
Purgatory is a state of purification where souls who die in God's grace and friendship but still imperfectly purified are assured of their eternal salvation, but after death, they undergo purification so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven.
Another important thing to note is the distinct meaning of guilt and punishment. When we commit any sin we will feel guilty, this guilt is removed by confession but temporal punishment remains and can be purified through penance and purgatory. For example, if someone steals a pen and later goes to confession, the guilt of the sin is forgiven but the harm caused by the act still remains. So, indulgence is the Church applying Christ's merit to remit temporal punishment. As I stated earlier, some people see it as buying forgiveness. Indulgences cannot be bought, cannot forgive future sins or permit a person to sin freely.
Biblical Foundation of Indulgence
An important thing to note is that everything the Catholic Church does, what we practice, what we believe and everything about the Church has a foundation, a source and can be traced; which is the deposit of our faith, the pillars of the Church: the Sacred Scripture, the Sacred tradition and the magisterium. Which means indulgence is not something made up by someone, it has long existed. Indulgence can be traced back to when Jesus Christ gave the apostles power to bind and loose in Matthew 16:19, Matthew 18:18; 2 Samuel 12:13-14 when David committed adultery with Bathsheba, Uriah's wife, the child born from that union died as a consequence of David's sin even though God forgave him. Also, 1 Corinthians 3:15 is understood as referring to purification after death.
Types of Indulgence
There are two kinds of indulgence
1. Partial Indulgence
2. Plenary Indulgence
Partial Indulgence: As the name implies, removes part of the temporal punishment due to sin.
Plenary Indulgence: This removes all temporal punishment due to sin.
Conditions to Gain an Indulgence
A very important factor to be qualified to gain an indulgence is satisfaction and this must be personal. They also include
1. Be in a state of grace.
2. Receive the Sacrament of Penance (confession)
3. Receive Holy Communion
4. Pray for the intentions of the Pope
5. Have complete detachment from all sins, even venial sin
Historical Development of Indulgence
This practice has been developed from early Church penances, and was designed to help penitents express sorrow and reconcile with the Church community. In the early Church especially from the third Century, under ecclesiastic authorities, they allowed a confessor to intercede for another Christian in order to shorten the other's canonical penance.
The Council of Epaon, which is now France, in 517AD, reduced to two years the penance apostates were to undergo on their return to the Church but they were also obliged to fast, to come to Church, and to take their place at the Penitent's door and to leave with the Catechumens, anyone who objects this, was to go through the long ancient Penance. This was called Canonical Relaxation and not indulgence yet.
In the 7th Century, the Penitential of Cummean counseled a priest to take into consideration when imposing a penance, the penitent's strength and weakness. They suggested that some Penances could be commuted through prayers or substitutions. It became a custom to commute Penances to less demanding work such as prayers, alms, fast and so on.
In the 10th Century, some penances were not replaced but reduced to pious donations, pilgrimages and similar meritorious works. In the 11th and 12th centuries, all these canonical penances began to be seen as a remission of the temporal punishment due to sin. A particular form of penance was practiced at that time, some confessors imposed participation in the crusades as an act of penance.
The earliest record of Indulgence was Pope Urban II's declaration at the Council of Clermont (1095), he remitted all Penance incurred by crusaders who has confessed their sins that attending that Crusade is equivalent to complete penance. This is generally regarded as the first clearly recorded plenary indulgence.
Around 1230 the Dominican theologian Hugh of St. Cher proposed the idea of a treasury at the Church's disposal consisting of infinite merits of Christ and the immeasurable abundance of the saints' merit. This was the basis for the theological explanation of Indulgence.
Indulgences were intended for the purpose of remission of temporal punishment which was equivalent to the ancient time when canonical penance was given. As purgatory became more prominent in Christian thinking, the Idea was developed that Indulgence may aid in the remission of temporal punishment purified in purgatory.
In the late Middle ages, abuses occurred where Indulgence were wrongly sold, this contributed to the Protestant Reformation, the Church responded to this by reforming the practice at the Council of Trent (1545-1563) which clarified that Indulgences are valid but selling them is strictly forbidden
Common Misconception about Indulgence
1. You can buy Indulgence: This was an aberration condemned by the Church. It existed, but the Church never formally taught that Salvation could be bought. The Council of Trent addressed this issue also, that grace cannot be bought.
2. Indulgences Permits us to sin: some people’s Idea is that once you gain an Indulgence, you are now clean and free from punishment, so you can commit any sin. Just like the misconception people have about the sacrament of Penance, ‘I will commit that sin and I will go for confession later.’
3. Indulgence is outdated: Many people believe this because it may seem true in this Gen Z era, that Indulgence are no longer practiced or indulgence are for old people, but this is not true. Indulgences are still part of the Catholic practices till today.
4. It is an automatic forgiveness: This is not an instant process, it is not an automatic forgiveness. It requires sincere repentance, conversion of heart, Prayer, charity and true contrition.
Partial Indulgence, in the past were counted in days and in years, but Pope Paul VI suppressed this and evaluate that partial Indulgence would no longer be measured in days or years. Also, there were many prayers circulating on prayer cards and prayer book which has Indulgence days attached to them but they are no longer valid.
Indulgence does not forgive the guilt of sin and it does not provide release from eternal punishment due to unforgiven mortal sin. Forgiveness of mortal sin is obtained through confession. Also the Church understanding of [Matthew 16:19] the power of binding and loosing given by Christ, in consideration of prayer or other pious works undertaken by faithful, the Church does not want to simply come to the aid of these people but also spur them to works of devotion penance and charity.
To gain any indulgence, whether partial or plenary, you must be in a state of grace, it can be applicable to oneself and can be offered for souls in purgatory, it cannot be applied to other living people.
Another important matter to discuss is who has the authority to grant indulgences?
The people that can grant indulgences are:
1. The Holy Father i.e. Pope.
2. Cardinal.
3. Archbishop.
4. Bishop.
5. Priest.
It’s important to note that the Pope has the universal authority or possess the fullness of authority to grant indulgence. Cardinals and Bishops may grant indulgence in their dioceses for special occasion, and within limit established by the Church law. A priest may impart certain indulgence if the authority is conferred on him.
Ways of obtaining partial indulgence
There are four general grants:
1. Raising the mind to God with humble trust, performing one’s duty and adding pious invocations.
2. Devoting oneself generously to works of charity and mercy
3. Freely abstaining from something in a spirit of penance
4. Freely giving open witness to one’s faith
According to Enchiridion (manuals or handbook) of Indulgences, a partial indulgence is granted to a faithful in conjunction with
1. Receiving the Sacrament of Penance
2. Holy Communion
3. Praying for the Pope’s intention
4. Making an act of faith, hope and charity
5. Spending more time in mental prayer
6. Penitentially praying prayers such as: Prayers from the Roman Breviary, to you O blessed Joseph, Angel of God, Anima Christi, Hail Holy Queen, Magnificat and so on
7. Visiting a Christian Catacomb (underground burial tunnel)
8. Praying for Christian unity and reconciliation of all Christians
9. Renewal of baptismal promise
10. An act of pilgrimage and religious actions and so on
March 20, 2020, a Plenary Indulgence was issued.
1. For COVID-19 victims and those helping them.
2. For COVID-19 victims at the hour of death.
3. Those who made an offering for end of the pandemic, prayer for those afflicted and salvation for the dead. The faithful could obtain the indulgence through acts such as Eucharistic adoration, praying the Chaplet of Divine Mercy or reading of the Bible
November 1st-8th every year, the Church grants a plenary Indulgence and may be obtained through, visiting holy sites(cemeteries), praying for the dead and the usual conditions (Confessions, Holy Communion, prayer for the Pope's intention, detachment from sin).
Plenary Indulgence
They include
1. Piously reading or listening to Sacred Scripture
2. Adoration of Jesus in the most Blessed Sacrament
3. The exercise of the Stations of the Cross
4. Praying the Rosary.
5. Participating in a spiritual retreat
6. Participation in World Youth Day, Eucharistic Congresses and similar events when declared by the Apostolic Penitentiary.
7. Receiving the Pope’s blessing through a life broadcast under the usual conditions.
8. Indulgences can also be granted during Jubilee year
Many of these acts must be observed for at least thirty minutes.
One interesting thing is that it is not only the Latin rite who practice this but also the eastern rite, though they are not always called indulgences and the Eastern Catholic Churches have analogous practices of evening prayer, prayer for the dead, prayer of thanksgiving, prayer for the Church and so on.
Why the Church encourages indulgences
1. It motivates prayer, reading of the Scripture and works of charity
2. Hope: It reminds us that we are part of a spiritual family and we can help one another
3. Spiritual discipline.
Finally, indulgence is a balance between God’s mercy and God’s justice. It reminds us that Salvation is not just forgiveness but also about transformation and restoration.
ONWE BENEDICTA CHIAMAKA
A student of Ladoke Akintola University of Technology Ogbomoso, Oyo State.


Leave a Comment